H.P. Lovecraft adaptations certainly aren’t rare, but despite a number of relatively faithful and sometimes even terrifying retellings, these movies seldom manage to replicate Lovecraft’s unique style. After all, the Rhode Island author infused his work with a peculiar blend of horrific excess and existentialist philosophy, so it makes sense that even masters of the […]
H.P. Lovecraft adaptations certainly aren’t rare, but despite a number of relatively faithful and sometimes even terrifying retellings, these movies seldom manage to replicate Lovecraft’s unique style. After all, the Rhode Island author infused his work with a peculiar blend of horrific excess and existentialist philosophy, so it makes sense that even masters of the craft like the late Stuart Gordon chose to focus on a single one of these elements when making adaptations rather than risking both.
However, there exists a criminally underseen duology of films that managed to overcome the inherent difficulty of adapting Lovecraft by bypassing his original work entirely and instead replicating the pulpy thrills of a certain tabletop RPG. Naturally, I’m referring to Spain’s The Valdemar Legacy and its sequel, The Valdemar Legacy II: The Forbidden Shadow (which is really just the second half of the same movie). With the Halloween season finally upon us, I believe this is the perfect time to look back on these films as unofficial adaptations of the Call of Cthulhu role-playing game!
Despite being considered a high-profile release in Europe, The Valdemar Legacy was actually an independent passion project brought to life by the blood, sweat, and tears of writer-director José Luis Alemán. A lifelong connoisseur of Weird Fiction, Alemán wished to combine his favorite scary stories into an epic pastiche made by genre fans for genre fans.
Unfortunately, the scope (and subject matter) of such a project made it nearly impossible to guarantee funding through the government subsidies that keep Spanish cinema alive – especially after the box-office failure of Stuart Gordon’s underrated Lovecraft adaptation Dagon.
Left with no other choice, Alemán decided to risk everything and finance the picture himself, selling off assets and picking up a few loans in order to bring his ambitious screenplay to life as a two-part epic. This resulted in Spain’s first major genre film produced without government resources!