‘Escape From New York’: John Carpenter Says Robert Rodriguez Has a New Story and Is the “Backup”
John Carpenter says Robert Rodriguez has a new Escape from New York story he wants to make, naming the From […]

John Carpenter says Robert Rodriguez has a new Escape from New York story he wants to make, naming the From Dusk till Dawn and Planet Terror filmmaker as a backup for the long-developing revival.
The comments come from Carpenter’s appearance on Dropping Names with Brent and Jonny:
“We have a backup,” Carpenter said. “Robert Rodriguez wants to. He has a new story he wants to do. So, we’ll see.”
That doesn’t establish that Zack Snyder (Dawn of the Dead) is out. Some reports have interpreted Carpenter’s remarks as an announcement that Snyder has departed, but the exchange includes overlapping dialogue about the filmmaker’s career. It isn’t a clear confirmation of a directing change.
As we reported in June, Snyder came aboard to write and direct a reimagining of Carpenter’s 1981 film, with Carpenter executive producing. The proposed approach emphasized practical effects and locations, closer to Snyder’s Dawn of the Dead than his bigger superhero productions.
Carpenter also wants to compose the new film’s music. Between that and his mention of another filmmaker with a different story, there’s clearly still interest in getting Snake Plissken back on-screen. What shape that ultimately takes remains the question.
I like that StudioCanal is pursuing this, although Snyder and Rodriguez feel like big-name, high-risk options to me.
I’m a fan of Snyder’s Dawn of the Dead and 300. Watchmen is spectacular as a comic book adaptation, even if admiring that accomplishment and finding it an entertaining movie aren’t quite the same thing for me. I really don’t like Sucker Punch, and while I respect the love people have for his DC films, that universe wasn’t for me.
Rodriguez is the filmmaker I’m more hesitant about, and I’ve been pretty vocal about that. Which is strange to say when his early work meant so much to me.
